A roofline that waves or dips, visible from the sidewalk
A roof should read as a flat plane between the ridge and the eave. Sections that sag between the rafters, or a ridge line that looks like it has a shallow dip in it, are the classic outward sign that the boards underneath have lost their stiffness. Stand across the street and look along the roof rather than at it.
The catch. If this shows up soon after a roof replacement, it points at the installation rather than at age.

