The Best Roofing Materials, by Cost and by How Long They Last
Eight materials, what each costs installed per square foot, how long each lasts, and the three Carolina conditions that decide which of them is actually right for your house.
The table
Every material, cost and lifespan
Cheapest first. The right answer is usually not the cheapest row, and it is almost never the most expensive one.
Material
Installed cost per sq ft
Lifespan
The short version
Asphalt shingle
$3.50 to $5.50
15 to 30 years
The default, and usually right
Metal
$7 to $22
45 to 100 years
Outlives two asphalt roofs
Concrete tile
$2 to $4
30 to 50 years
Cheap, but heavy
Clay or ceramic tile
$2 to $10
20 to 100 years
Near permanent, brittle
Wood shake
$4.80 to $5.25
20 to 30 years
Character, needs upkeep
Synthetic
$1 to $15
Up to 50 years
Slate look, light weight
Rubber
$25 to $40
Up to 50 years
Flat and low-slope only
Solar shingle
$21.50
Up to 30 years
Power first, payback second
Cost and lifespan ranges from This Old House. Ranges are national. Triangle pricing sits inside them, and the spread within each material is mostly product grade and roof complexity.
In brief
The same eight, one line each
For when the table is more than you needed.
Asphalt shingle, $3.50 to $5.50 per sq ft
The default on roughly four out of five houses around here, and the default for good reasons. Cheapest to buy, cheapest to fix, every crew in the state can install it. Lifespan 15 to 30 years.
Metal, $7 to $22 per sq ft
Standing seam is the one worth having. Roughly double the cost of architectural asphalt and it outlives two of them, so the arithmetic works if you are staying put. Lifespan 45 to 100 years.
Concrete tile, $2 to $4 per sq ft
Cheap per square foot and rated past 150 mph wind, but it weighs around 900 pounds per square. Most Triangle framing was never designed for that, so budget for a structural check. Lifespan 30 to 50 years.
Clay or ceramic tile, $2 to $10 per sq ft
Beautiful and close to permanent when it is installed properly. Brittle underfoot, needs a crew who has done it before, and the same weight question as concrete. Lifespan 20 to 100 years.
Wood shake, $4.80 to $5.25 per sq ft
Ages well and insulates well. In North Carolina humidity it also asks for real maintenance, and fire ratings are worth checking against your insurer before you commit. Lifespan 20 to 30 years.
Synthetic, $1 to $15 per sq ft
Polymer shingles that imitate slate or cedar at a fraction of the weight. The wide price band is real: the cheap end and the good end are different products. Lifespan up to 50 years.
Rubber, $25 to $40 per sq ft
A flat and low-slope material, not a pitched-roof one. Relevant for a porch, an addition or a commercial deck, not for the main house. Lifespan up to 50 years.
Solar shingle, $21.50 per sq ft
Generates power and looks like a roof. Expensive, harder to find anyone to service, and less efficient per square foot than ordinary panels on a rack. Lifespan up to 30 years.
The real comparison
Asphalt against metal, which is the only choice most people face
Strip out the materials that are wrong for a typical Triangle house and you are left with two. Architectural asphalt at the lower end, standing seam metal at the upper.
Asphalt runs $3.50 to $5.50 a square foot installed and lasts 15 to 30 years. Metal runs $7 to $22 and lasts 45 to 100. So metal is roughly double the money and roughly triple the life, which means on a long enough horizon it wins, and on a short one it does not.
The horizon that matters is how long you are staying. Under ten years you will never see the payback, and you will not get it out of the sale price either, because buyers do not price roofs that carefully. Past twenty years, one metal roof against two asphalt roofs plus the disruption of the second tear-off is a genuinely close contest, and metal often takes it.
Everything else on the table is a special case. Tile and concrete for weight and looks, wood for character, synthetic when you want the look of slate without the structural conversation, rubber for flat sections, solar when the power matters more than the payback. Our metal roof against shingles comparison goes deeper on the two that matter.
Choosing in the Triangle
The three local conditions that override the national averages.
01
Humidity rules out some of it
Wood shake ages well in a dry climate. In Carolina humidity it asks for real maintenance and the fire rating is worth checking against your insurer first.
02
Hail favors impact rating over material
Wake County logged 69 hail events between 2020 and 2025. A Class 4 impact rated asphalt shingle often beats an unrated premium material here, and costs a great deal less.
03
Weight decides the tile question
Concrete tile is around 900 pounds per square. Most Triangle framing was not designed for it. Get the structural check before you fall in love with the look.
04
Ventilation decides the lifespan
Whichever material you pick, a hot deck shortens it. Ventilation is the cheapest line on a roofing quote and the one most often cut.
Keep reading
Related comparisons and guides
The shingle detail behind the asphalt row, and who installs each of these locally.
GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning and IKO on published specs.
Prefer to write to us?
Send us a message
We’re always here to help! Whether you just have a general question or you are wanting to schedule a FREE inspection, fill out the form and someone from our team will be in contact with you.
By pressing submit, you agree to receive email, text, and/or voice updates. Carrier fees may apply.
Roofing material questions
What is the best roofing material overall?
For most Triangle homes, architectural asphalt with a Class 4 impact rating. It is the best combination of cost, lifespan and hail resistance. Standing seam metal is the better answer if you are staying more than twenty years.
What is the longest lasting roofing material?
Metal and tile, both quoted up to 100 years. Metal is the practical one in North Carolina because tile brings a structural weight question with it.
What is the cheapest roofing material?
Synthetic starts lowest at around $1 per square foot, but the cheap end of that range is a very different product from the good end. Asphalt at $3.50 is the cheapest material you can buy with confidence.
Is a metal roof worth it in North Carolina?
If you are staying past twenty years, usually. One metal roof outlives two asphalt ones, and you skip a tear-off. Under ten years the money does not come back to you.
Does roofing material affect home insurance?
It can. Impact resistance is the factor most insurers price, and a Class 4 rated roof often earns a discount. Ask your insurer for the number specific to your policy before you choose.
How much does a new roof cost in Raleigh?
A typical 2,000 square foot home runs $12,900 to $17,000 in architectural shingle with a full tear-off. Standing seam metal is roughly double. Our roof replacement cost guide breaks it down by roof size.
